Elvis Presley – “Tell Me Why”

Composed by the enigmatic Titus Turner in 1956, “Tell Me Why” predates Presley’s recording by nearly a decade. The original version, released by R&B singer Marie Knight, gained some traction in the southern US, particularly in New Orleans and Texas. The song itself is a slow-burning rhythm and blues ballad, with a melody that some have likened to the gospel standard “Just a Closer Walk With Thee.” This subtle religious undercurrent adds a layer of depth and yearning to the lyrics, a perfect canvas for Presley’s powerful vocals.

The story behind the 1957 recording by Presley is almost as interesting as the song itself. Legend has it that the performance was shelved because it bore too strong a resemblance to the aforementioned gospel tune. RCA Victor, Presley’s record label, wouldn’t let this gem gather dust forever. By 1965, with Presley entrenched in Hollywood and churning out soundtrack material, the label saw an opportunity. The musical landscape had shifted since Presley’s early rockabilly days, and “Tell Me Why” seemed to fit the evolving sound of the times. This time around, the gamble paid off. The song, released under the producerial eye of the legendary Steve Sholes, became a gold record, reaching number 33 on the Billboard Hot 100 and an impressive number 15 on the UK Singles Chart.

“Tell Me Why” stands as a testament to Presley’s versatility. Here’s a man who could ignite a stage with his electrifying rock and roll, yet he could also deliver a soulful ballad with a depth and sincerity that rivaled any R&B crooner. The song is a reminder that Presley wasn’t just a musical phenomenon; he was an interpreter, a conduit for a range of emotions and styles. “Tell Me Why” lets us hear a more introspective side of the King, a man wrestling with love, doubt, and the complexities of relationships. It’s a song that showcases not just his undeniable charisma, but also his remarkable vocal prowess. So, put on your blue suede shoes, metaphorical or otherwise, and prepare to be swept away by the King’s timeless plea: “Tell Me Why.”