Introduction:
Toby Keith’s song “What Made the Baby Cry?” stands out in his discography as a contemplative Christmas-themed track, exploring the deeper emotions surrounding the nativity story. Released on his 1995 holiday album Christmas to Christmas, the song presents a poignant perspective by reflecting on the birth of Jesus from a somber and introspective angle. Keith questions if, even as an infant, Jesus could feel the weight of humanity’s sorrows and burdens, lending a unique, reflective layer to the Christmas music landscape. Rather than focusing solely on holiday cheer, the song invites listeners to ponder the hardships and trials that lie ahead for humanity.
Known primarily for his patriotic hits and lively country anthems, Toby Keith took a different route with this song, embracing themes of vulnerability and introspection. The song’s narrative suggests that even in a moment of pure joy, like a birth, there is an underlying awareness of life’s complexities and the difficult path that might await. This thoughtful approach aligns with Keith’s reputation as a storyteller, allowing him to delve into meaningful questions about faith and the human experience.
What Made the Baby Cry? is more than just a seasonal tune; it’s a song that encourages reflection on life’s dualities, especially within the context of spirituality and compassion, making it an understated but impactful piece in Toby Keith’s catalog. For those interested in a Christmas song that goes beyond typical festive themes, this track offers a rare depth and introspection within country music.
Video:
Lyrics:
“What Made The Baby Cry?”
As the snow fell to earth
That’s the one night, we remember
When a woman gave birth
And for miles and miles around
The baby’s cry was the only soundDid He know the world was filled with pain
Could He feel all the hunger and the shame
Or did He know about the way He would die
And the reason why
Is that what made the baby cry?
Is that what made the baby cry?
As his Mother turned to hold Him
Her face filled with joy
He grew quiet when She told Him
He was more than just her baby boy
And for miles and miles around
Her lullaby was the only sound
Did She know the world was filled with pain
Could She feel all the hunger and the shame
Or did She know about the way He would die
And the reason why
Is that what made Her baby cry?
Is that what made Her baby cry?
And as He fell asleep
She wiped away His tears
But the question still remains
Have we changed in two thousand years
Don’t you know the world is still in pain
Can’t you feel all the hunger and the shame
Did we forget about the way that He died
And the reason why
Would we still make the baby cry?
Would we still make the baby cry?